The current study focuses on the impact loading phase characteristic of thin first year ice in inland waterways. We investigate metal grillages, fibre reinforced plastic (FRP) composites and nature-inspired composites using LS Dyna. The impact mode is modelled as (a) simplified impact model with a rigid-body impactor and (b) an experimentally validated ice model represented by cohesive zone elements. The structural concepts are investigated parametrically for strength and stiffness using the simplified model, and an aluminium alloy grillage is analysed with the ice model. The metal–FRP composite was found to be the most favourable concept that offered impact protection as well as being light weight. By weight, FRP composites with a Bouligand ply arrangement were the most favourable but prone to impact damage. Further, aluminium grillage was found to be a significant contender for a range of ice impact velocities. While the ice model is experimentally validated, a drawback of the simplified model is the lack of experimental data. We overcame this by limiting the scope to low velocity impact and investigating only relative structural performance. By doing so, the study identifies significant parameters and parametric trends along with material differences for all structural concepts. The outcomes result in the creation of a viable pool of lightweight variants that fulfil the impact loading phase. Together with outcomes from quasi-static loading phase, it is possible to develop a lightweight ice-going hull concept.